In the world of anime, a complex character is often a big plus, but sometimes that very complexity sparks endless debates among fans.
Here are 7 names that alone can split forums into two opposing camps: passionate defenders and harsh critics.
7. Eren Yeager (Attack on Titan)
Eren is definitely one of the most controversial characters ever created. Starting as a righteous hero, the story’s brutal twist turned him into the series’ main villain. To protect his people, Eren became as ruthless as those who once killed them.
Although his actions are wrong, the deeply realistic and humane character development keeps many fans from turning their backs, creating intense inner conflict among viewers.
6. Katsuki Bakugo (My Hero Academia)
Bakugo has one of the most impressive redemption arcs, but his past still holds him back. His brutal bullying of Deku early on left a lasting negative impression on many viewers.
Even though Bakugo now works hard to change and take responsibility for his actions, his fiery temper keeps him both at the top of fan favorite lists and the target of heavy criticism.
5. Light Yagami (Death Note)
Although the protagonist, Light was never a hero. His appeal lies in his absolute belief in his extreme sense of justice, which won over many fans who supported “Kira’s” path.
On the other hand, half the fandom strongly opposes him and sides with L. Light is a prime example of a brilliantly written character who can manipulate viewers’ emotions.
4. Sakura Haruno (Naruto)
Sakura is often seen as a victim of the author’s pen. Compared to Naruto and Sasuke, she had fewer chances to shine, with much of her story revolving around her feelings for Sasuke. This led to harsh criticism labeling her useless, while defenders argue she is a realistically developed character amidst a team of “monsters.”
3. Subaru Natsuki (Re:Zero)
Subaru is a deeply flawed protagonist, which adds realism but can also be frustrating. Many viewers struggle with his clumsiness and immature personality in the early stages.
However, other fans see his weaknesses and failures as his greatest strengths, making his journey of growth all the more meaningful.
2. Griffith (Berserk)
Griffith’s complexity is staggering. From an admired leader, his horrific betrayal turned him into the number one enemy. Some fans try to understand his motives, but for most, what he did is unforgivable.
1. Gabi Braun (Attack on Titan)
While Eren divides fans over ideals, Gabi is hated for her direct actions: she killed Sasha, one of the most beloved characters. Gabi’s fanaticism and blind faith early on made viewers strongly dislike her. Although she later realizes her mistakes, for many, her attempts at redemption come too late.